Rachelle Schwartz

“I am no bird; and no net ensnares me.”
In these words by Charlotte Bronte, Jane Eyre declares with audacious authority the individuality and free will that she, as a “free human being” inherently possesses and has the right to. Using the comparison of a bird is not uncommon in discussions of freedom (sometimes, I have even believed it overused), but here, it stood out to me. I have only recently begun to notice why.
Here, Jane Eyre uses the bird to symbolize a lack of freedom. Traditionally, the wings and flight of birds have given them a sense of easy, unquestioned freedom. A simplicity: if they do not like where they are, they simply flap their feathers and go somewhere else. Charlotte Bronte’s use of birds is for the opposite purpose. Jane Eyre is not noticing the characteristic freedom of birds, she is noticing how easily this freedom is encaged, and how quickly liberation is stripped from the innocent and defenseless. She is not saying the bird does not deserve to be free, she is saying she refuses to have her rightful and inherent right to freedom be treated with that same kind of disrespect. She is separating herself from the perceived weakness of the bird. But this weakness is just that: perceived.

In reality, birds are not much weaker than the rest
of us. To have the freedom of flight requires something of the bird’s anatomy. They must be lightweight, so they have evolved to have hollow bones. People often take this to mean that the
bones are easily broken. However, contrary to popular belief, birds are not fragile creatures. Some research shows bird bones to be even stronger than those of land animals in some ways.
Maya Angelou notices this strength with her use of the bird metaphor.
Birds sing all the time, even when there seems to be nothing to sing about. I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings and its poetic counterpart, Caged Bird, answer the question of what a creature born to fly, but forced to stand behind the bars of a cage, wings clipped and talons tied, could have to sing about. What art
can be made from the air of imprisonment? Angelou writes:
“The caged bird sings
with a fearful trill
of things unknown
but longed for still
and his tune is heard
on the distant hill
for the caged bird
sings of freedom.”
When captured, the last means of escape is through their downy throats. Their song is not a song of celebration like the birds outside the windows, it is an act of protest. She specifies that
this bird was born in a cage by saying it has never known freedom; still, the bird hungers for it. Freedom is a more primal urge than I think we realize. Something within us is hypnotically taken with it, even if we have never experienced the kind of freedom we are craving.
This reminded me of Suzanne Collins’s use of the Mockingjay, a fictional bird, in The Hunger Games as a symbol for the political rebellion aimed at taking down a corrupt government. Most of the characters fighting against the injustice of their government have never known any other way of life, but they are very aware that things are not right, and far from fair. Harper
Lee used them to represent the unprovoked killing of a nonviolent thing in To Kill a Mockingbird. This is probably on of the more famous examples, but uses of bird metaphors in literature are endless. They are symbols of hope, peace, and resistance. Whatever they come to represent, though, they all have something in common: they are acknowledging a certain trade off in belonging to a society. There is a certain amount of wing-trimming we all must do to remain within the confines of security. We cannot dance naked in public, we cannot eat fruit from trees that do not belong to us, we cannot eat at all actually until we give somebody money. Even at the most basic, peaceful, and nonviolent level, living in a society centered on ownership and monetization can never allow for real freedom because in
this world you cannot do anything without money, a deed, or a weapon.
Humans seem to have a an interest, an envy, for the freedom of the bird. How often do we hear characters express a wish to be a bird when we read or watch television. I was a little embarrassed with myself one evening last November when I found myself absentmindedly musing on my own longing to be a bird. The evening was crisp. One could no longer ignore the imminence of winter, or the way it crushed the orange embers of past hopes into cooling ashes, waiting patiently for disposal. I insisted on sitting outside as I did my homework, even though it was more than a little chilly, because I knew it would be one of the last times I could do so before the snow came and the freeze settled deep into the dirt. Instead of looking down at the plethora of final exams, projects, and papers on my dull laptop screen of due dates and time charts, my eyes were on the sky, and I didn’t particularly mind. There were a few birds taking turns swooping and twirling above the fountain outside the library. They seemed to be dancing, carefree and playful. I wanted nothing more in that moment than to be just like that: detached from the worries of the ground, in a complete and utter lack of walls, the openness of the cool air in my throat, completely alive and, somehow, completely unconcerned with that fact. I was embarrassed at first to be the vessel of such a commonplace desire. I felt pedestrian and childish. But why should I be ashamed of wanting something just because everyone else wants it too? We all want freedom for a reason. We deserve to have it. I envied those birds so much that evening.
Birds have come to represent so many things for humans because we see so much of ourselves in them. They show us ourselves from many directions like a room of mirrors. They represent our freedom, our oppression, our rebellion, our peace, our potential, our reality. To cage them is inherently symbolic because they themselves are symbolic. Just as Harper Lee attests in To Kill a Mockingbird, the killing of a sacred thing is a statement in itself. It has implications beyond the isolated act. It involves more than the bird and the bullet. The bird metaphor is not overdone; I am no longer ashamed to be writing just one of many accolades to the birds.
We sympathize with birds so easily because the resilience of their spirit mimics the indomitability of our own. It echoes with something somber and restrained, but ready to soar. Emily Dickinson said, “Hope is the thing with feathers – That perches in the soul.” This language of “perching” is important. The bird is staying still, the bird is latching to something; but it is staying there for a reason, and it can leave whenever it wants. Suzanne Collins’s villain, President Snow, said that a little hope is good, but too much was dangerous because it gave people incentive to rise against that which oppressed them. Hope is rebellious. Hope is how we choose freedom even when it is not within grasp; it’s the freest thing about us.

















